Blog/The Blog/How Christie Nasypany-Cicero Rebuilt Her Identity After Hockey

How Christie Nasypany-Cicero Rebuilt Her Identity After Hockey

Unpublished

Showing Up When Everything Falls Apart
​The Story of Christie Nasypany-Cicero

Christie Nasypany-Cicero’s story is one that every athlete, coach, and parent needs to hear.
From the outside, her life looked like a dream—Division I hockey player, college coach, respected leader in the sport she devoted her life to. But behind the scenes, Christie was silently battling a mental and emotional collapse she didn’t see coming.

Her turning point didn’t come on the ice.
It came at the lowest moment of her life—when she could barely leave her house, when anxiety consumed her, and when she lost the identity she’d built since she was two years old.

And yet… she showed up.
Not perfectly, not confidently, not with answers—
but courageously.

This is what rising above adversity really looks like.

Christie's Story: When Hockey Becomes Your Entire Identity

Christie laced up skates at age two. From that point on, hockey wasn't just something she played - it was who she was. 

Her entire childhood and young adulthood revolved around it.
She played Division I at Mercyhurst, competed with and against world-class players, and then transitioned into college coaching.

But when her playing career ended, so did the identity she had relied on.
She didn't feel worthy.
She didn't know who she was outside of hockey.
And coaching felt like the only way to feel "whole" again.

That's when the real adversity began.

Christi Nasypany-Cicero - hockey
The Confident Athlete Shirt

Wear the Mindset. Live the Message

The Confident Athlete and This Is Good gear is finally here!

Now you can rep the mindset both on and off the court. Whether you're a basketball player grinding through adversity or an athlete showing up with purpose, our apparel is designed to remind you—and everyone around you—what you're about. It's Not Just What You Wear. It's Who You Are!

this is good hat
Christi Nasypany-Cicero - hockey

The Breakdown She Never Saw Coming

While coaching, Christie suddenly began experiencing debilitating anxiety.
Not nerves.
Not stress.
But overwhelming panic—at home, on the road, even during recruiting trips.

One day she drove 11 hours to watch a recruit, left the game without warning, drove all the way back, walked into her team’s rink, then abruptly left again—feeling out of control and terrified of her own emotions.

Within days, she was unable to leave her home.
If her fiancée didn’t text back within 15 minutes, she feared the worst.
Her mind simply would not shut off.

And then came another blow:
Her head coach asked her to resign, telling her she was “hurting the program.”

That moment broke her.

Christie questioned everything—her value, her identity, her future, her purpose.
And for the first time in her life… she felt like giving up.

Christi Nasypany-Cicero - hockey

The Turning Point: "I Need Help."

There is a single moment that Christie says saved her life:
She looked at her fiancée and said:

“I don’t know how to fix this. I need help.”

This was her defining Challenger Deep moment.
Not glamorous.
Not heroic.
But real.
Raw.
And courageous.

That simple act of showing up—imperfectly—set her on the path to rebuilding her identity, healing her mental health, and discovering the life she was meant to live.

Christi Nasypany-Cicero - hockey
Christi Nasypany-Cicero - hockey

What Christie Learned (and Every Athlete Needs to Hear)

1. Showing up is the foundation of overcoming adversity
You don’t need the answers.
You don’t need to feel brave.
You don’t need to pretend you’re okay.

You only need to show up.
That small step creates every breakthrough that comes later.

2. Your sport cannot be your entire identity
Christie hid inside hockey to avoid facing anxiety, pain, and unresolved struggles.
Many athletes do the same.

Your sport is part of you—
but never all of you.

3. Vulnerability creates connection
The myth that athletes must be “tough enough” to suffer alone is destroying careers and mental health.
Opening up isn’t weakness.
It’s strength.
It’s clarity.
It’s healing.
​
​4. Coaches must look beyond the athlete and see the person
Christie highlights a crucial warning:
If athletes feel like they’re only valued for their performance, they will hide their struggles until it’s too late.

​Every athlete needs at least one person who sees them—not just their stats.

Christi Nasypany-Cicero - hockey

Christie's Lessons for Athletes, Coaches, and Parents

For Athletes:

  • Ask for help early
  • Lean on teammates you trust
  • Don't let your identity disappear into your sport
  • Your mental health determines your performance - not the other way around

For Coaches:

  • Your athletes are human beings first
  • Create space for conversations outside the sport
  • Recognize when "pushing harder" is not the answer
  • Build a culture where vulnerability isn't punished

For Parents:

  • Notice when your athlete is hiding behind their sport
  • Encourage balance
  • Celebrate character, not just performance

Key Takeaways

  • Adversity does not care how strong you appear—it reveals how strong you truly are.
  • Your identity must be built on something deeper than your sport.
  • Asking for help is not a collapse—it’s a turning point.
  • Vulnerability is the gateway to connection, healing, and growth.
  • The strongest athletes are the ones who show up, even when they don’t feel strong.

Get a 14-day free trial of The Confident Athlete Program and access our full suite of mindset tools for athletes, coaches, and parents:

👉 www.ConfidentAthleteProgram.com

📘 Get your copy of Challenger Deep: Athletes Rising Above Adversity here: www.JeffHeggie.com/freebook 

This episode is sponsored by dōTERRA — the global leader in essential oils and natural wellness solutions. As a listener of the Challenger Deep podcast, you can unlock 25% off all dōTERRA products and supplements.

​Start your journey to peak performance and recovery with the purest plant-based tools on the planet: www.ConfidentAthleteProgram.com/doterra

25% Off Your dōTERRA Products & Supplements

This episode of The Challenger Deep: Athletes Rising Above Adversity Podcast is brought to you by dōTERRA, the world leader in essential oils and wellness products.

Listeners of this podcast can get 25% off dōTERRA products and supplements. Click HERE to start your journey to peak performance today.

We all face adversity. It's how we choose to respond to it that determines who we become...

Discover how to turn challenges into triumphs with Challenger Deep: Athletes Rising Above Adversity.

Get your FREE copy now!
Packed with strategies, stories, and tools to build resilience and success.

Check out other episodes of The Challenger Deep: Athletes Rising Above Adversity Podcast:
​https://www.jeffheggie.com/blogs/challenger-deep

Jeff Heggie Profile Photo Square no background.png

Jeff Heggie

Success Coach

Make 2025 Your Best Year Yet: The Strategy to Transform Resolutions into Reality

Don't Wait Another Day... Your Dream Life Starts with This Decision

The Confident Athlete Newsletter #16 - December 2024

Creating a Life of Abundant Choice: The Business Opportunity You've Been Waiting For

Imagine Building a Business With Unlimited Potential

Unlock the Cheat Codes for Success: Start Your Entrepreneurial Journey Today

The Confident Athlete Newsletter #15 - November 2024

The Game Changing Secret to Athletic Success: Better Sleep

4 Week Win Challenge: Boost Productivity, Wellness, and Success

The Confident Athlete Newsletter #14 - October 2024

How to Build a Business That Gives You Time Freedom and Financial Flexibility

The Confident Athlete Newsletter #13 - September 2024

The Confident Athlete Newsletter #12

Unlock Unshakable Confidence: Join The Confidence Challenge!

Discover How a Successful Entrepreneur Transformed Skepticism into Massive Success

Unlocking Time Freedom and Financial Success